Who Holds the Power? Rethinking Power in the Workplace


 
Golden key representing Power in the Workplace

Power has a mixed reputation. For many, it conjures images of hierarchy, authority, control and people exerting influence over others.

And that's largely how we've come to understand it: who holds power, how they exercise it and how they influence others.

Psychologists John French and Bertram Raven helped shape how we understand power, largely through authority, expertise and influence over others.

But is this the whole picture?

 

At Heart@Work, we believe our understanding of power needs to go further. Beyond the power we hold and the influence we have over others, there is the power that comes from within us, and the power that emerges when we create together.

Four dimensions of Power

Our Integral Model of Power brings together four interconnected dimensions, each representing a distinct source of power that shapes how people, teams and organisations function.

Every dimension has the potential to enable or constrain. Recognising both its power and its shadow is essential to exercising power well.

1. Structural power - the power of the system.

The traditional understanding of power. It comes from formal authority, decision rights, control over resources and information, roles, policies, incentives and consequences. Structural power establishes who can make decisions, allocate resources and direct action.

Organisations need it, but authority is only one source of power.

Its shadow: When structural power becomes concentrated, rigid or overly controlling, it can create bureaucracy, reinforce hierarchy, limit autonomy and silence alternative perspectives. The structures designed to enable work can end up constraining it.

2. Relational power - the power between us.

Relational power is shaped by how others perceive, respond to and relate to us. It comes from two sources:

  • Earned power – what we do. The trust, respect and influence we build through our behaviour, relationships, consistency and interactions with others.

  • Ascribed power – who we are. The status, credibility or influence attributed to us because of our social identity and demographic characteristics, such as gender, race, age, cultural background or socioeconomic status.

These two sources don't always align. Someone may have considerable expertise and integrity yet have their credibility questioned because of a perception about who they are. Equally, someone may be afforded status and influence without having earned it. Together, these dynamics shape whose voices are heard, whose contributions are valued and who gets to influence.

Its shadow: Relationships can become vehicles for manipulation, exclusion or control. Influence can be used to protect personal interests, create alliances, withhold information or reinforce existing power dynamics rather than build trust and connection.

3. Personal power - the power I bring.

Personal power is about recognising and bringing our full selves to what we do. Personal power comes from two complementary sources:

  • Authenticity and alignment – who I am. Knowing ourselves, understanding what we believe and value, and having the courage and agency to act in alignment with these. It's the integrity between what we say, believe and do.

  • Expertise and knowledge – what I know. The skills, knowledge, experience and capabilities we bring.

Personal power is realised when we bring both together: when we know who we are, recognise what we have to offer and have the confidence and agency to act on it.

Its shadow: Personal power can become self-serving when authenticity turns into an excuse for self-interest, confidence becomes arrogance, or expertise becomes a reason to dismiss other perspectives. Equally, a lack of personal power can show up as passivity, self-doubt or an unwillingness to speak up.

4. Collective power - the power we create together.

Collective power can take different forms. It can emerge when people unite around a shared purpose, cause or goal, combining their numbers, voices and resources to achieve something they couldn't achieve alone.

But it can go further. When people bring their personal power and engage with one another through trust, openness and mutual respect, something more becomes possible. They build on each other's thinking, challenge assumptions and generate new insights, possibilities and solutions that no individual could have created alone.

This is the generative potential of a we-space – something created between us, rather than simply by us. It's where collective intelligence, co-creation and emergence come to life.

Its shadow: Collective power can become groupthink, conformity or mob mentality. A strong sense of belonging can create insiders and outsiders, while the desire for consensus can suppress dissenting voices and discourage challenge.


Where are we out of balance?

Power is rarely neutral in how it is exercised. Each dimension can enable, connect and create, but also control, constrain and exclude. The challenge isn't to eliminate power, but to recognise how we hold it, how we use it and where it may be out of balance.

In our experience, organisations tend to over-rely on two dimensions of power, while leaving two others significantly under-leveraged.

The dimensions often over-leveraged include:

  • Structural power: Organisations can rely heavily on hierarchy, positional authority, formal processes and decision-making structures to get things done. While necessary, an over-reliance on structural power can create bureaucracy, dependency on authority and limited autonomy.

  • Relational power: Influence often flows through established relationships, networks, alliances and informal hierarchies. While relationships are essential, power can become concentrated in particular groups, reinforcing exclusion, favouritism and existing power dynamics.

The dimensions often under-leveraged include:

  • Personal power: People often have the expertise, skills and experience to make a valuable contribution, but don't fully exercise their personal power. They hold back, defer to authority or compromise their convictions. The capability is usually there; what's missing is often the authenticity, confidence or courage to act in alignment with who they are and what they know.

  • Collective power: Organisations consistently under-leverage what they could achieve together. People work in silos, contribute their individual expertise and focus on their own responsibilities, but don't bring their collective intelligence to bear on bigger challenges. We coordinate activity, but don't necessarily create together.

These are significant missed opportunities.

Playing with power

The real value of the model is in using it to create new possibilities. It gives us a different lens through which to examine how power operates and, more importantly, how we might use it differently.

  • Notice which forms of power are strong, which are underused and which might be out of balance.

  • What could you do differently to strengthen another dimension? The invitation is to experiment. Shift how power is exercised, create space for different forms of power to emerge.

  • Reflect and learn - what shifts? What becomes possible?

The most powerful results come from a healthy balance - people who are grounded and capable, in trusting relationships, within enabling structures, creating together.

Power, reimagined

At Heart@Work, we believe the future of work requires a different relationship with power. One grounded in alignment within ourselves, connection between people and unity across the systems in which we work.

The greatest power in an organisation isn't what one person holds. It's what becomes possible when people are empowered to bring their best, connect meaningfully and create together.

We don't just need to redistribute power. We need to expand what we understand power to be – and what we're capable of creating with it.


Want to unlock the power in your organisation?


Next
Next

The Hidden Flaws in Strategic Planning